Butterbeer = Epic Fail!

We finally got around to trying out Hagrid's recipe for Butterbeer.  Thing #1 was so excited to try it out.  She helped prepare the recipe.  It sure smelled and looked really good.

Problem was?

She didn't like the taste.  At all.

I have to admit it was a bit sweet for me.  Good, but way sweet.  We decided that perhaps Hagrid was cheated by the owner of the Three Broomsticks and that it wasn't really the "real" Butterbeer recipe!

Thing #2 thought it was really good though.

Thing #3 didn't like it much, either.

Thing #4 took one taste and spit it out in the sink.

Hagrid's recipe for Butterbeer?

Epic Fail.

(hmmm, not sure why the photo is sideways.  Oops!)